Then again, as I said, upon second read, I can definitely see Lee thinking this, especially if he hangs around a lot with the twins.
Which was most of why I wrote that, although there's also the fact that especially in drabbles, I tend to work with semi-charicatures of the Houses, which in the case of Gryffindor means "too stupid to be afraid". (Er, yes. I'm a real bitch about these things sometimes. <g>)
The Curves Of Your Lips Rewrite History
I think you make a good point about reversing the order, but like you said, it's a matter of whether the starting point is canon or fanon, and for me, the starting point should always be canon. I don't even see the last one as being fanon so much as it's the third possible outcome of things as they are now, but then I tend to try and forget anything I know of HP fanon in the first place and just work with what's in my head. But I see your point. :)
but then I tend to try and forget anything I know of HP fanon in the first place and just work with what's in my head.
I see your point, too, and I agree canon should be the starting point. However, most people sadly have been in fandom for a long time, and I, personally, simply can't switch off what I know about fanon while reading. *shrug* I hung out at hp100 for a while (and still do, occasionally), and it always struck me how it was usually those drabbles that stuck closest to canon that hit me most -- simply because I'm not expecting it anymore. People are wont to write sickly-sweet, angsty Remus/Sirius, for example, or Snape/Harry, for that matter, and when someone just happens not to, it hits me right where I live, because it hurts, but in a good way. So, er, yeah. Tangents. *ahem* ;-)
I, personally, simply can't switch off what I know about fanon while reading.
And I think I should perhaps think about that more when making editing choices, because I think a lot of people are influenced by fanon, and forgetting that will change the reaction I get from my audience, I think.
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
![[identity profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/openid.png){kind=small}
From:
Re: Feedback, at last...
Which was most of why I wrote that, although there's also the fact that especially in drabbles, I tend to work with semi-charicatures of the Houses, which in the case of Gryffindor means "too stupid to be afraid". (Er, yes. I'm a real bitch about these things sometimes. <g>)
The Curves Of Your Lips Rewrite History
I think you make a good point about reversing the order, but like you said, it's a matter of whether the starting point is canon or fanon, and for me, the starting point should always be canon. I don't even see the last one as being fanon so much as it's the third possible outcome of things as they are now, but then I tend to try and forget anything I know of HP fanon in the first place and just work with what's in my head. But I see your point. :)
From:
Re: Feedback, at last...
I see your point, too, and I agree canon should be the starting point. However, most people sadly have been in fandom for a long time, and I, personally, simply can't switch off what I know about fanon while reading. *shrug* I hung out at
From:
Re: Feedback, at last...
And I think I should perhaps think about that more when making editing choices, because I think a lot of people are influenced by fanon, and forgetting that will change the reaction I get from my audience, I think.