Well, his age dictates against the "irredeemable" part--plenty of people have ideas and notions at 14 that would horrify them just a few years later--and we don't know as of yet how much of what he says he's parroting from his own father...but just *dismissing* all of it as many of the apologists do is ridiculous in the extreme.
The Cedric thing was just the last straw for me; especially as I rather liked Cedric for his own sake. Don't get me started on *my* Harry/Cedric musings, or we'll be here all day. ;-)
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
no subject
Date: 2001-08-16 10:36 am (UTC)The Cedric thing was just the last straw for me; especially as I rather liked Cedric for his own sake. Don't get me started on *my* Harry/Cedric musings, or we'll be here all day. ;-)