(no subject)

[bubosquared]

To: Poppy Z Brite
From: A bewildered ex-fan
Re: This

Yo

WTF? I concur with Ang. your badge of coolness is revoked. Here, have a "Big Fat Hypocrite" one instead.

(Oh and incidentally, it is entirely possible to be biologically female, male-gendered, and yet not rag on women, you know. Just a thought. If you don't believe me, there's this mate of mine you ought to meet.)

Absolutely no love whatsoever,
Melle

Comments

[darksong.livejournal.com]

I think Poppy is a pretty good writer and mostly a nice person (with the couple indirect encounters I've had with her online). I do, however, pretty much think she's a freak, and not so much in a good way.

She has strong opinions, and I don't think she necessarily thinks them through before she says them. I think she likes to try to antagonize people.

I do think it's silly of her to say that slash isn't valid, especially when the books of hers I've read seem to put across the idea you can only find true love and happiness in a male homosexual relationship.

I do agree with your comment on her ragging on women, though--I do think that even if she regards herself as being of the male gender, there's still a part of her that is female. I think we as a society are too busy trying to put things into black and white terms. You can be both, and there's nothing wrong with that.

[usual.livejournal.com]

Oh, mate, could be worse. Eat it, eat it, get yourself an egg and beat it...

[armistice.livejournal.com]

See, I'd read that article before, though I'm not sure where or when, and it never occurred to me to be offended by it. Think about it. The very first bit of slash I read was a very bad ST:TNG fic that I stumbled upon. The next ten or so stories I read were also very bad. If I hadn't been 13, and I'd actually realized that they were bad, I probably would have branded all slash as bad writing and moved back to het.

She hasn't read much slash. I'm betting that what she has read were of average ff.net quality. And having that impression of slash fiction, I wouldn't want anything I'd written to be labelled as "slash" either. She probably isn't aware that people think of the definition of "slash" in such broad terms, and she may not even know that RPS exists (and since both of her slash stories were RPS...)

As for her gender issues, well. She doesn't like being a woman, she doesn't feel like a woman, and she wants everyone and their mother to know it. She gets that across by being as derivative toward females as she can be without alienating the majority of her audience. It's not cool, and it's really very childish, but. She's got issues.

someone should remind Ms. Brite

[icanreadyourmnd.livejournal.com]

that she has a HUGE on-line fandom and that she, at one time, was a new author. I remember when cause I was there for it ... her old Abyss editor now runs a New England writing program and sends graduated authors my way for representation.

whether she gets slash or not is her problem, putting it down however is a problem. Porn is porn. And some of it is damn good. Period.

By teh way, Melle-ski, how's your novel coming and did you get your copy of the signed contract in the mail yet?